# Apache Subversion 1.10 Release Notes

## What's New in Apache Subversion 1.10 ¶

- Improved path-based authorization
- New interactive conflict resolver
- LZ4 Compression
- Shelving (experimental)
- Many enhancements and bug fixes
- Known issues in the release

Apache Subversion 1.10 is a superset of all previous Subversion releases, and is as of the time of its release considered the current "best" release. Any feature or bugfix in 1.0.x through 1.9.x is also in 1.10, but 1.10 contains features and bugfixes not present in any earlier release. The new features will eventually be documented in a 1.10 version of the free Subversion book (svnbook.red-bean.com).

This page describes only major changes. For a complete list of changes, see the 1.10 section of the CHANGES file.

## Compatibility Concerns ¶

Older clients and servers interoperate transparently with 1.10 servers and clients. However, some of the new 1.10 features may not be available unless both client and server are the latest version. There are also cases where a new feature will work but will run less efficiently if the client is new and the server old.

There is no need to dump and reload your repositories. Subversion 1.10 servers can read and write to repositories created by earlier versions. To upgrade an existing server installation, just install the newest libraries and binaries on top of the older ones.

Subversion 1.10 maintains API/ABI compatibility with earlier releases, by only adding new functions, never removing old ones. A program written to any previous 1.x API can both compile and run using 1.10 libraries. However, a program written for 1.10 cannot necessarily compile or run against older libraries.

There may be limited cases where the behavior of old APIs has been slightly modified from previous releases. These are cases where edge cases of the functionality has been deemed buggy, and therefore improved or removed. Please consult the API errata for more detailed information on what these APIs are and what impact these changes may have.

### New Feature Compatibility Table ¶

New Feature | Minimum Client1 | Minimum Server | Minimum Repository | Notes
--- | --- | --- | --- | ---
Improved path-based authorization | any | 1.10 | any | Existing authz configurations may need to be adjusted.
New interactive conflict resolver | 1.10 | any | any | Use SVN 1.8 and above clients only for best results.
LZ4 compression over the wire in http:// and svn:// connections | 1.10 | 1.10 | any |
LZ4 compression in the backend storage | any | 1.10 | 1.10 | FSFS only
1Reminder: when using the `file://` repository access method, the Subversion program is both the client and the server.

### Upgrading the Working Copy ¶

Subversion 1.10 uses the same working copy format as Subversion 1.8 and 1.9.

Before using Subversion 1.10 with an existing Subversion 1.7 or older working copy, users will be required to run the `svn upgrade` command to upgrade working copy metadata to the new format. This command may take a while in some cases, and for some users, it may be more practical to simply checkout a new working copy.

Note: Subversion 1.10 cannot upgrade working copies that a 1.6 client would have refused to operate upon before an `svn cleanup` was run (with a 1.6 client). In other words, before upgrading to 1.8 or newer, a 1.6 or older client must be used to run `svn cleanup` on all 1.6 or older working copies that require cleanup. Likewise, Subversion 1.10 cannot upgrade corrupt working copies. Unfixable problems can arise from missing or corrupt meta-data inside `.svn` directories. Such damage to the working copy is permanent, and cannot be fixed even if `svn cleanup` is run prior to the upgrade.

If your working copy does not upgrade cleanly, please check out a new one.

### Miscellaneous Compatibility Notes ¶

There are some additional specific areas where changes made in this release might necessitate further adjustment by administrators or users. We'll cover those in this section.

#### This release is numbered 1.10 ¶

Since "1.10.0" is smaller than "1.9.0" when considered as ASCII strings, scripts that compare Subversion versions as strings may fail to correctly determine which of "1.10.0" and "1.9.0" is the more recent one. Such scripts should be changed to compare Subversion version numbers correctly: as tuples of integers, with an optional suffix for development or pre-release versions. See the Subversion release numbering documentation for details. (Programs written against the C API or the various bindings should refer to the `svn_version_*` interfaces.)

#### New path-based authorization compatibility ¶

The improved path-based authorization changes the behaviour of some existing authz files.

The 1.9 and earlier implementations allowed multiple rules for the same path:

      [/some/path]
      userA = r
      [/some/path]
      userB = rw

In 1.9 this would define access for both `userA` and `userB`, in 1.10 this raises an error and no access is possible.

The 1.9 and earlier implementations allowed multiple entries matching the same name, alias or group and the last match applied:

      [/some/path]
      user = rw
      user = r
      &alias = rw
      &alias = r
      @group = rw
      @group = r

In 1.9 the final, read-only, match for `user`, `&alias` and `@group` would be selected while 1.10 combines all the lines to give read-write access. The 1.10 implementation may change in future releases, perhaps to make this case an error.

A fix for Issue #4762 may change the way path-based authorization rules are applied in some circumstances. See r1882326.

Background: Subversion 1.10 introduced a new implementation of path-based authorization (authz) to deliver wildcard support and improved performance over that of Subversion 1.9 and earlier. From Subversion 1.10 through 1.14.0, the new implementation did not correctly combine global rules with repository rules: if a global rule and a per-repository rule were both present for a path, the global rule would be ignored and the per-repository rule would apply by itself. As a result, from Subversion 1.10 through 1.14.0, it was not possible to override per-path access rules for specific users (or groups) at the global level. Administrators whose authz rules rely on this incorrect behavior may need to adjust their rules accordingly.

This issue is fixed in 1.14.1, making it possible once again to override per-path access rules for specific users (and groups) at the global level. Such global rules are overridden by repository-specific rules only if both the user and the path match the repository-specific rule.

As an example, consider the following rule set:

    [groups]
    company = developer1, developer2, developer3
    customer = customer1, customer2

    # company can read-write on everything
    [/]
    @company = rw

    [project1:/]
    @customer = r

Does `developer1` have `rw` access to `"/trunk"` in `project1`?

Subversion servers running 1.10.0 up to 1.10.6 or 1.14.0, without the fix for issue #4762, will only apply the repository-specific part of the rule set:

    [project1:/]
    @customer = r

The answer in this case is that `developer1` has no access at all because the global rule which grants `rw` access to the `@company` group is ignored.

Subversion servers running 1.14.1 or later match the behaviour of Subversion 1.9, meaning they will apply both the global and the repository-specific part of the rule set:

    # company can read-write on everything
    [/]
    @company = rw

    [project1:/]
    @customer = r

The answer in this case is that `developer1` has `rw` access to any path in `project1`. Global rules are overridden by repository-specific rules only if both the user (`developer1`) and the path (`"/"`, including child paths for which no specific rules exist) match the repository-specific rule. While the repository-specific rule matches `"/trunk"` it does not match `developer1`, and hence the global rule will be used.

#### `svnadmin` subcommands print locked paths differently ¶

The `svnadmin lock`, `svnadmin unlock`, and `svnadmin rmlocks` subcommands print the locked path differently.

In 1.9 and earlier, the path would be printed out in exactly the form it was input. In 1.10, the path is printed in "canonical" form: with dot components (`foo/./bar`) elided and multiple slashes (`foo//bar`) compressed to one. The path also starts with a slash in the output, regardless of whether a leading slash was present in the input.

Example:

    $ svnadmin-1.9 lock r //iota jrandom logmsg opaquelocktoken:42
    '//iota' locked by user 'jrandom'.
    $ svnadmin-1.9 unlock r //iota jrandom opaquelocktoken:42
    '//iota' unlocked by user 'jrandom'.

    $ svnadmin-1.10 lock r //iota jrandom logmsg opaquelocktoken:42
    '/iota' locked by user 'jrandom'.
    $ svnadmin-1.10 unlock r //iota jrandom opaquelocktoken:42
    '/iota' unlocked by user 'jrandom'.
    $

Only the output is changed. The set of valid inputs and the behaviour of `svnadmin` on them are unchanged. `svnadmin` continues to accept paths either with or without multiple slashes, dot components, and so on as command-line arguments.

#### `svnserve` honours `use-sasl = true` when built without SASL ¶

The behaviour of `svnserve` when built without support for Cyrus SASL transport has changed.

In Subversion 1.9 and earlier, `svnserve`, when built without SASL support, would ignore the `svnserve.conf` `use-sasl` setting; In Subversion 1.10, `svnserve`, when built without SASL support, errors out if `use-sasl` is set to `true`.

`svnserve`'s behaviour is otherwise unchanged. In particular, the behaviour of builds with SASL support is unchanged.

An API erratum is available.

#### New CA keys may be required ¶

Some binary distributions of this new Subversion version may link to a newer OpenSSL version than previous distributions. This may lead to different behavior.

Especially, some distributions may link this Subversion release to OpenSSL 1.1 instead of OpenSSL 1.0. OpenSSL 1.1 does not allow md5 hashes for CA keys anymore. When using client certificates signed by such a CA, the new Subversion client may fail with `An error occurred during SSL communication`. You can analyze the underlying cause by first converting the client certificate from p12 to pem by

    openssl pkcs12 -in path/to/svn/cert.p12 -out cert.pem

and then testing the SSL connection by

    openssl s_client -connect example.com:443 -servername example.com -cert cert.pem

If this test connection fails with `ca md too weak` then creating new CA keys using sha256 instead of md5 and corresponding new client certificates should solve the problem.

See also When performing Subversion operations over SSL, I get the error `An error occurred during SSL communication`

## New Features ¶

### Improved path-based authorization ¶

Subversion 1.10 provides a new implementation of path-based authorization with improved performance and wildcard support. There are some compatibility issues.

Existing authz rules come in two flavours, repository-specific and global:

       [repos:/path]
       [/path]

In these rules, `/path` is always matched literally.

The new authz rule parser supports two new forms for rules which may contain wildcards in the path element:

       [:glob:repos:/path]
       [:glob:/path]

The following wildcard syntax elements are supported in glob rules:

- `*` matches a single (exactly one), arbitrary path segment
- `**` matches an arbitrary number of path segments, separated by a forward slash: `/`
- Classic wildcard patterns such as `*foo*.bar` work as expected, including escaping of special characters with a backslash: `\`

All wildcards apply to full path segments only, i.e. `*` never matches `/`, except for the case where `/**/` matches zero or more path segments. For example, `/*/**/*` will match any path which contains at least 2 segments and is equivalent to `/**/*/*` as well as `/*/*/**`.

Because a glob rule is not required to contain wildcards in the path, two sections with different names may apply to the same path. For example, the following two rules are identical:

       [/path/without/wildcards]
       [:glob:/path/without/wildcards]

The new authz rule parser detects and rejects such collisions.

The old authz parser, in Subversion 1.9 and earlier, allowed syntactic entries which grant write-only access. For example:

       [/]
       * = w

The new parser flags such entries as invalid. Neither the old nor the new authz implementation support write-only access.

### New interactive conflict resolver ¶

Subversion 1.10 provides much better interactive resolution of tree conflicts than previous releases. Interactive conflict resolution has been completely redesigned and rewritten. This new conflict resolver supersedes the first implementation introduced in Subversion 1.5.

The new conflict resolver searches repository history for structural changes (additions, deletions, copies, and moves) which conflict with local changes in the working copy and cause tree conflicts. Tree conflicts are now described in detail, including revision numbers and names of authors of conflicting changes. In previous versions of Subversion, the task of finding such information was left to the user. Automating this task is a huge usability improvement.

The new conflict resolver is able to detect moves and renames in repository history, and take them into account while modifying the local working copy. This makes seamless merging between branches possible even if one or both branches rename files or directories. For best results, all SVN clients committing to the repository should be at version 1.8 or higher.

The new conflict resolver will avoid asking users about resolution options whenever there is a only one reasonable course of action. For example, if a file was moved to another location in the repository, the conflict resolver will attempt to resolve the tree conflict on behalf of the user by performing the same move locally if necessary. This allows users to focus their attention on conflicts which cannot be resolved automatically.

Because detection of moves and renames involves heuristics, detection is not perfect and won't work in all conceivable cases. For a detailed description of how incoming moves and renames are detected, see How Subversion's conflict resolver handles incoming moves.

The conflict resolver user interface remains largely unchanged. Like in previous releases, the resolver will be started automatically if an update, merge, or switch operation ends with unresolved conflicts. It can also be started on demand by running the `svn resolve` command. For more information, run `svn help resolve` after installing Subversion 1.10.

In some situations, resolving one tree conflict will cause new other tree conflicts to appear. The `svn resolve` command will keep iterating over such conflicts until none are left, or until the user decides to quit the operation.

The new conflict resolver can be driven interactively with `svn resolve`, from Subversion's client API (in C and other language bindings), or with the non-interactive svnconflict tool which is intended for use in shell scripts.

The new conflict resolver offers a variety of automated tree conflict resolution options which users can choose from. Not all kinds of tree conflicts can yet be described and resolved. The options available in Subversion 1.10.0 are listed in the table below. In this table, the items on the incoming and local side are either both files or both directories. Most cases where files clash with directories are not handled yet.

Future releases of Subversion will continue to provide enhancements for the new conflict resolver. We expect to add coverage of additional conflict cases and add additional resolution options even in patch releases (i.e. in 1.10.1, 1.10.2, etc.).

local change | incoming change | operation | resolution options
--- | --- | --- | ---
edit file any change inside a directory | delete file / directory | update, switch, merge | ignore deletion accept deletion
move file / directory | update, switch, merge | move and merge (applies the same move locally and merges items)
add item | add item | update, switch | ignore incoming addition (discards the incoming change) merge incoming and local item
merge | ignore incoming addition (discards the incoming change) merge incoming and local item (item's log history will trace back on local branch) replace local item with incoming item, then merge them (item's log history will trace back to other branch)
move item | edit file any change inside directory | update, switch | apply change to move destination break move and update any moved away children (updates items moved outside of the moved directory)
merge | apply change to move destination
delete item | edit file any change inside directory | update, switch, merge | keep working copy state (deleted file / directory), discarding incoming changes

### LZ4 compression ¶

Subversion 1.10 adds support for LZ4 compression as an alternative to the zlib compression that has been used in the previous versions. LZ4 offers fast compression and decompression while still maintaining a decent compression ratio. Using LZ4 compression can significantly improve performance of most of the Subversion read and write operations, especially for repositories containing large files.

LZ4 compression is now used by default for the on-disk data in repositories with filesystem format 8. Also, Subversion 1.10 adds support for automatic negotiation and use of LZ4 compression over the wire for http:// and svn:// connections when it is supported by both endpoints.

#### Filesystem format bump ¶

The default filesystem format is now version 8, introduced in 1.10. The format bump is required to allow using LZ4 compression for the data that is stored on the disk. (The `svnadmin info` command displays the filesystem format number of a repository.)

Existing repositories can be upgraded to the new format with the `svnadmin upgrade` command.

#### Configuring the repository to use LZ4 compression ¶

Repositories created with Subversion 1.10 and existing repositories upgraded to format 8 will by default compress new data using LZ4. The compression algorithm can also be configured explicitly by setting the `compression = none | lz4 | zlib | zlib-1 ... zlib-9` option in the `fsfs.conf` repository configuration file.

Existing repositories with the configured `compression-level` option in the `fsfs.conf` file will continue to use zlib compression. In order to start using LZ4 compression for such repositories, consider setting the `compression = lz4` option in the `fsfs.conf` file.

In order to speed up read and write operations for existing repositories, consider recompressing the data stored in them with LZ4. This can be achieved by performing a full dump/load cycle into a new format 8 repository created with Subversion 1.10.

#### LZ4 compression over the wire in http:// and svn:// connections ¶

Deltas transferred between Subversion 1.10 clients and servers may be compressed with LZ4. The actual choice of the compression algorithm depends on the used protocol, environment and its configuration — see below.

For the http:// protocol, use of LZ4 compression depends on the values of the server-side `SVNCompressionLevel` directive, client-side `http-compression` configuration option and on the network capabilities. LZ4 compression generally offers much faster compression and decompression speeds, but slightly worse compression ratio than zlib. By default, it is only preferred for low latency networks where the overhead associated with transferring the additional amount of data is assumed to be negligible.

- On the server-side, `SVNCompressionLevel 0` can be used to disable compression altogether. The special value of `SVNCompressionLevel 1` forces the use of LZ4 compression for clients that support it. All other values result in preferring zlib compression with the respective compression level. Note that the negotiated algorithm is still subject to the client's configuration. For example, even if the server is configured to prefer zlib compression over LZ4, a client may still negotiate the use of LZ4 compression when its `http-compression` option is set to `auto`.

- On the client-side, setting `http-compression` to either `yes` or `no` will enable or disable compression that is then negotiated based on the server's configuration. The default value of `auto` will result in preferring LZ4 compression for low latency networks and zlib compression otherwise.

Below is the table explaining the used compression algorithm in each combination of the client- and server-side configuration options:

| 1.10 Server with SVNCompressionLevel: | 1.9 and older Server with SVNCompressionLevel:
--- | --- | ---
Subversion Client | 0 | 1 | 2-9 (default: 5)* | 0 | 1-9 (default: 5)*
1.10, `http-compression: auto`*, low latency | None | LZ4 | LZ4 | None | zlib
1.10, `http-compression: auto`*, high latency | None | LZ4 | zlib | None | zlib
1.10, `http-compression: yes` | None | LZ4 | zlib | None | zlib
1.10, `http-compression: no` | None | None | None | None | None
1.9 and older, `http-compression: yes`* | None | zlib | zlib | None | zlib
1.9 and older, `http-compression: no` | None | None | None | None | None

* Default configurations

For the svn:// protocol, use of LZ4 compression depends on the value of the server-side `-c/--compression` option. A value of `0` disables compression entirely; any other value causes lz4 or zlib compression to be used. At this time, lz4 is always used in preference to zlib when both are supported by the remote end.

### Shelving (experimental) ¶

Shelving (issue #3625) is the ability to put aside an uncommitted change in the WC, as if putting it on a shelf, in order to work on something else, and later bring the change back in to the WC. It is very similar to saving a patch file created by `svn diff` and later applying it with `svn patch`.

The following `svn` commands are new; see their help for details.

- `svn shelve [--keep-local] NAME [PATH...]`
- `svn unshelve [--keep-shelved] [NAME]`
- `svn shelve --delete NAME`
- `svn shelves` (or `svn shelve --list`)

WARNING: The shelving feature is designated "EXPERIMENTAL" in 1.10. It is being released in an early form while development continues. It is expected to change significantly during and after the 1.10.x series. There is no promise of backward compatibility while it remains experimental.

## Enhancements and Bugfixes ¶

### Command-line client improvements (client) ¶

#### `svn log --search` improvements ¶

`svn log --search` is now case-insensitive and ignores diacriticals when matching words. This makes it easier to match paths and log messages which happen to contain upper-case and non-English characters.

#### New `svn ls --search` option ¶

You may now specify one or more glob patterns in a `svn ls` request. Note that most shells require globs to be put in quotation marks to be passed as-is to SVN. Example:

       svn ls svn://server/repo --recursive --search "readme*"

Against a Subversion 1.10 server, this command will be executed as a single, efficient server-side query.

#### `svnbench` improvements ¶

`svnbench` now displays its wall-clock run time and the total number of bytes transferred across the network. The `--with-no-revprops` option which did not actually work in Subversion 1.9 has been fixed.

#### New option `--accept recommended` ¶

The new option `--accept recommended` will automatically resolve tree conflicts for which a recommended resolution option is available. Any other conflicts will be postponed.

Note that `--accept recommended` is now the default behaviour if the `--non-interactive` option is used. In previous releases, the `--non-interactive` option implied `--accept postpone` by default instead.

### Server-side improvements ¶

#### Revprop caching enabled ¶

Revprop caching was an optional FSFS feature in previous releases but is now always enabled. In previous releases revprop caching could be enabled for mod_dav_svn via the `SVNCacheRevprops` directive, and for svnserve by the `--cache-revprops` command line option. That directive and command line option are now silently ignored and revprop caching is enabled for all FSFS access.

#### New `--no-flush-to-disk` option for `svnadmin load` ¶

A new `--no-flush-to-disk` option has been added to the `svnadmin load` command. This option can be used to dramatically speed up the load process when there is no need to ensure that the resulting data survives a system crash or power loss, e.g. when loading a dump file into a fresh repository.

#### New `--normalize-props` option for `svnadmin load` ¶

A new `--normalize-props` option has been added to the `svnadmin load` command. This option can be used to automatically repair non-LF line endings in properties such as `svn:log` or `svn:ignore`. Such invalid line endings were accepted by older servers and can be found in repository dumps of older repositories, but are rejected by Subversion 1.6 and later.

Calling `svnadmin load` with `--normalize-props` will automatically repair all invalid property line endings found in the dumpstream, thus ensuring that the appropriate values are loaded into the repository.

#### New `svnadmin dump-revprops` and `svnadmin load-revprops` subcommands ¶

svnadmin can now dump and load revision properties independently of other changes made to the repository. This is useful because revision properties are not versioned but their values may change if the administrator has configured the repository's pre-revprop-change hook.

`svnadmin dump-revprops` will save the current values of all revision properties to a dump file. `svnadmin load-revprops` can be used to set revision properties in a repository to the values saved in a dump file.

#### `svnadmin dump` can now include or exclude paths (issue #4729) ¶

New `--include` and `--exclude` options have been added to the `svnadmin dump` command. Using --exclude or --include gives results equivalent to authz-based path exclusions. In particular, when the source of a copy is excluded, the copy is transformed into an add (unlike in 'svndumpfilter').

A `--pattern` option allows the include or exclude rules to contain wildcards (the same as in 'svndumpfilter').

### Client- and server-side improvements ¶

#### RA-serf now compresses deltas when possible ¶

RA-serf now sends deltas compressed when possible, unless compression is disabled by the '`http-compression = no`' client configuration option. This is enabled for servers that advertise support for this specific (new) capability.

mod_dav_svn servers now advertise this specific (new) capability.

Ref. r1704317, r1704891, r1791290.

## Known issues in the release ¶

There are some known issues in the Subversion 1.10 releases. These may be fixed in later 1.10.x releases. Selected issues are listed here; see the issue tracker for details and for other issues.

### SVN-4741: authz group cannot refer to multiple groups ¶

Broken in 1.10.0. Fixed in 1.10.1.

### SVN-4762: authz doesn't combine global and repository rules ¶

Broken in 1.10.0 and 1.10.1. See also path-based authorization compatibility.

## Subversion 1.9.x is now the old stable version ¶

The Subversion 1.9.x line is now the old stable version. This means that 1.9.x will still receive security relevant fixes as well as bugfixes. While we will evaluate any bugreport with regards to its severity, there might be issues with a lower severity which will only get fixed in 1.10.x, particularly if the patches would be invasive, destabilizing, and/or require a significant investment to get backported to the old stable version.

Therefore, if you are running into an issue with the old stable version which has already been fixed in the latest version, we might ask you to upgrade to that version to resolve the issue.

## Subversion 1.8.x is end of life ¶

The Subversion 1.8.x line is end of life (EOL). This doesn't mean that your 1.8 installation is doomed; if it works well and is all you need, that's fine. "End of life" just means we've stopped accepting bug reports against 1.8.x versions, and will not make any more 1.8.x releases.